WENZEL, BENNETT & KOWALSKI, P.C.

LAND CONTRACTS:
FORECLOSURE VERSUS FORFEITURE

 

BY: DOUGLAS A. KOWALSKI

MARCH 29, 1995

There are basically two types of legal action which can be taken in response to a default (non-payment) by a land contract vendee. One type of action is called a land contract forfeiture and the second is called a land contract foreclosure.

A land contract forfeiture seeks to accomplish payment of all arrearage to bring the land contract current, including interest, costs, and expenses such as taxes, etc. In the event the purchasers are unable to bring the land contract current, a forfeiture action seeks return of the property to the seller. Forfeiture actions are relatively quick. They are generally less expensive then foreclosure actions. However, forfeiture actions where the purchasers bring the contract current by paying principal interest, costs and expenses result in the continuation of the land contract. As the vendor, you may run into similar collection problems in the future if the vendee again fails to keep current on the land contract payments.

A land contract foreclosure differs from a land contract forfeiture in that it accelerates the entire amount owed on the land contract including principal, interest, costs and expenses such as taxes and insurance. In order for the purchaser to avoid foreclosure, they must pay this entire amount resulting in full payment of the land contract. If purchasers are unable to do this, the action will result in a judgment for the amount owed and for sale of the property to apply against the amount owed.

The procedure for a foreclosure is as follows:

1. File a complaint for foreclosure against the purchasers and any other parties having an interest in the property. This is filed in the Circuit Court in the County where the property is located. (Prior to filing the Complaint, you should also order a title commitment to determine the status of legal title to the property. Any parties to whom the vendees may have given an interest must be joined in the suit).

2. The Defendants may file an answer raising any defenses which they may have within 28 days of being served. If they do not do so, a default will be entered and you would proceed to take a default judgment against them.

3. A hearing or hearings are held and the judge ultimately decides whether judgment of sale should be ordered. The Judge has discretion to allow vendees to bring the contract current under some circumstances.

4. Once a judgment of sale is entered which contains the full amount owed on the land contract including principal, interest, costs and expenses (actual attorney fees are not included in the judgment), the property can be sold at a sheriff's sale. The judgment may also contain various things such as an "upset price" which is the minimum amount that the property can be sold for.

5. According to Michigan statute, the property can not be sold until three (3) months have passed from the entry of the judgment of sale. This is apparently to allow the purchasers to pay off all monies owed before the expenses of sale are incurred.

6. During the three (3) month waiting period, a notice describing the property, place of sale and date and time of sale must be posted at three (3) locations in the county. This notice must also be published in a local newspaper as required by statute.

7. Assuming purchasers do not pay all monies owed prior to the sale, the sheriff conducts a public sale and accepts all bids made on the property. The sheriff accepts the highest bid which must be paid to him at the sale. You may bid at the sale as vendor and if your bid is the highest you need only pay what your bid exceeds the judgment amount, including sale costs, etc. Of course, most vendors only bid the judgment amount and, usually, the vendor is the only bidder.

8. The sheriff then issues what is called a sheriff's deed to the property which must be recorded at the Register of Deeds office within 20 days of the sale. This deed identifies the parties to the action, the date of the land contract, when and where it was

recorded, a description of the property, and when the deed becomes operative. This deed will become operative six (6) months after the sale according to statute.

9. After the sale, an Order Confirming the Sale must be presented to the judge for signing. This order acknowledges that the property was sold, to whom and the price. Once signed, the order is recorded at the Register of Deeds.

10. During the six (6) months redemption period before the deed becomes operative, the vendors or someone on their behalf, may "redeem" the property by paying all monies owed including the costs of the sale. This money may be paid to the purchaser at the sale or to the Register of Deeds. [If additional monies for taxes or insurance are paid by a purchaser after the sale, they should file an Affidavit with the Register of Deeds stating what the payment was for and include a receipt. These amounts are then added to the redemption amount and must be paid in order to redeem.] Should redemption occur, the deed becomes void.

11. If someone other than you purchases the property at the sale, you are entitled to the judgment amount including the costs of sale at that time. If you bid and are the highest bidder, one of two things will occur. If vendees redeem, you will be paid the judgment amount plus costs incurred. If they do not redeem, you will receive title to the property at the end of the six (6) months.

A foreclosure involves time-consuming complexities which make it a more expensive and lengthy remedy then forfeiture. On the other hand, it is intended to be a more permanent remedy. If your vendees are continuously behind on their land contract payments, you should consider this option.

 

WENZEL, BENNETT & KOWALSKI, P.C.
109 N. Second Avenue, Suite 200
Alpena, Michigan 49707
Telephone (989) 356-6128; Facsimile (989) 356-3524
E-Mail: lawyers@northernlaw.com